Built environment

When to Hire a Design Firm Like Gensler—and When to Buy OSB and Cement Board Yourself

By Emilia Novak

In early 2024, my company expanded from 400 to 650 employees and took over two floors of a second building. Six weeks into the renovation, our facilities manager quit. I inherited two very different procurement tasks: evaluate architecture and design firms for the fit-out, and source construction materials—bulk OSB board and cement board—for the contractors. I had zero construction background.

Eighteen months later, here's what I can tell you: there is no single right answer. Whether you should hire a global design firm like Gensler or manage material sourcing yourself depends on your project's scope, your internal capacity, and your risk tolerance. This guide walks through the three scenarios I've now been through firsthand.

What Gensler Actually Is

If you're searching "gensler architecture" or "gensler company profile," the short version is this. Gensler is a global architecture and design firm founded in 1965 by Art Gensler and Drue Gensler in San Francisco. It has grown to become one of the largest architecture firms in the world by revenue, consistently ranking at or near the top of Architectural Record's annual list of top architecture firms (Source: Architectural Record annual rankings). You've likely seen their work: the Shanghai Tower, SFO International Airport Terminal 2, the Empire State Building observatory renovation, and countless corporate headquarters.

Gensler's name comes up constantly in corporate interiors and workplace strategy—which is why everyone mentioned them when we started looking for an architect for our fit-out. They're large enough to have in-house specialists for materials, construction administration, and even furniture standards. But whether that scale works for your project is a separate question.

Here's something vendors won't tell you: most design firms, Gensler included, don't make meaningful revenue from material procurement. Their fees come from design work. That means their material specifications are relatively neutral—there's no hidden incentive to push you toward specific products. The bias you need to watch for lives in design-build contractors who mark up materials 15-30%. That's where the conflict of interest shows up.

The Three Scenarios

In my experience, every commercial construction or renovation project falls into one of three situations. The right move for your design and material purchasing decisions depends on which one you're in.

Scenario A: Large-Scale Project—Hire the Global Firm

If your project involves any of the following, you want a fully credentialed architecture firm:

  • Structural modifications or building permits with drawings that need an architect's stamp
  • Multi-floor corporate headquarters (50,000+ sq ft)
  • Complex MEP coordination with tenant improvements
  • Zoning, floor-area-ratio, or local jurisdiction approvals

In these cases, the firm's registration and professional liability insurance are not optional. The permit office will require stamped drawings. Your landlord's engineering team will require coordination documents. A firm like Gensler brings all of that in-house.

What most people don't realize: for a 100,000 sq ft corporate space, architecture fees usually run 5-8% of total construction cost. On a $40M build, that's $2-3.2M. It feels like a lot—until you see what a single design error costs in change orders. I watched a $180,000 cost overrun happen on a 3,000 sq ft executive suite because the lighting layout had a drafting error.

In this scenario, your material procurement role is narrow but still critical: you verify that the specifications the architect provides are commercially reasonable. When Gensler's team specified a specific cement board for a restroom core, I had to check whether the specified product's lead time would hold the schedule. It wouldn't. I sourced an ASTM C1325-compliant equivalent with two-day availability instead.

The lesson: hiring a great architect doesn't mean you stop evaluating materials. It means you evaluate fewer materials, more carefully.

Scenario B: Mid-Size Fit-Out—The Awkward Middle

This is the zone where I see buyers make the most mistakes. A 10,000-40,000 sq ft tenant improvement doesn't require a global architecture firm, but it's also not a simple cosmetic refresh. You need space planning, building-code compliance, and a lighting plan.

Here's the counter-intuitive part: I'd rather hire either a global firm like Gensler or a small specialized studio—not the mid-size regional firm that seems like a reasonable compromise.

Why? I tested this in our own request for proposals in 2024. We sent the same scope to three firms: a global practice (Gensler), a regional mid-size firm, and a small interior design studio. The global firm's fee proposal was only 8% higher than the regional firm's. The small studio was 35% lower. The regional firm sat in the most awkward position: they didn't have Gensler's global resources or research, but their billing rates were already approaching that level. We got better per-dollar value by deciding between the two ends of the spectrum, not the middle.

In this scenario, your material sourcing becomes more hands-on. A smaller design team will rely on you for material selection and costing, so you need to evaluate OSB board and cement board manufacturers yourself. This is where the second half of this article comes in.

How to Evaluate Cement Board Manufacturers

Over the past year, I've evaluated cement board suppliers for three projects. Here's my process:

  1. Check certifications first, not last. Look for ASTM C1288 (fiber-cement sheets) or ASTM C1325 (cementitious backer units) compliance in the technical data sheet. If the manufacturer can't produce a current, dated test report from an independent laboratory, don't shortlist them. (Source: ASTM International standards.)
  2. Request a cement board catalog from each shortlisted manufacturer. A real one—with product dimensions, thicknesses, edge profiles, and installation details. The manufacturers who hand you a one-page sell sheet, rather than an actual catalog, are telling you what their support will look like later.
  3. Order samples from at least three manufacturers. Not just a sample of the board. Ask for edge samples and cut one board diagonally yourself. Look at the fiber distribution. Cheap cement board shows uneven fiber clumps at the cut edge—that means weak spots that can crack during installation.
  4. Ask about lead times in writing. Every manufacturer will tell you "6-8 weeks standard" verbally. Get it in an email. In Q3 2024, a manufacturer that quoted 8 weeks took 14. Another that quoted 10 weeks delivered on day 68. We built a schedule buffer because of the first miss.
  5. Request a mill certificate. A mill certificate is a batch-level test report. If a supplier hesitates to share one or offers excuses, that tells you everything you need to know about their process transparency.

Honestly, I'm not sure why cement board pricing varies so wildly across manufacturers—we saw variations of 40% for products that appeared technically equivalent. My best guess is production scale and regional freight advantages matter more than most people account for. If a quote comes in dramatically lower than others, ask why. Sometimes the answer is legitimate. Sometimes it's not.

Scenario C: Straightforward Build—Skip the Big Firm

If you're doing a simple renovation with no structural changes, no new permits, and standard finishes, you probably don't need an architecture firm. Our 2023 breakroom renovation was exactly this.

I managed it internally with a trusted general contractor. We bought 156 sheets of 23/32" OSB for wall sheathing and cement board for a 200 sq ft pantry wet area. Total construction cost was $140,000. An architecture firm would have added $8,000-12,000 in fees for what was, frankly, a straightforward layout.

The catch: that approach works only if you can handle three things yourself:

  • Code compliance — Your GC should handle this, but you need to verify they're pulling permits in their name and that their insurance is current.
  • Material specifications — You need to review the GC's material list. This is where knowing your OSB grades and cement board types matters. A GC will often pick the cheapest available equivalent unless you specify otherwise.
  • Vendor accountability — If your GC orders materials without your visibility, you won't find out about shipping damage or batch quality issues until the install is underway. I now require GCs to provide mill certificates for cement board and batch numbers for OSB on every order.
An informed customer asks better questions and makes faster decisions. The projects that went smoothly weren't the ones where I trusted the team most—they were the ones where I understood the specs and could push back. I'd rather spend 10 minutes explaining options than deal with mismatched expectations later.

Bulk OSB Board Purchasing: Notes from a Non-Expert

If "bulk osb board" is how you landed here, here are the takeaways I'd want someone to hand me:

  • OSB is graded per APA (American Plywood Association) standards. Look for "Exposure 1" or "Exterior" ratings if there's any moisture risk. For interior sheathing, you can save 10-15% with Exposure 1 over Exterior (Source: APA panel grading guidelines).
  • 7/16" OSB is the most commonly stocked thickness for wall sheathing in bulk orders, but 23/32" is what most commercial specs call for in structural applications. Don't let a distributor substitute one for the other.
  • Bulk pricing as of January 2025: 7/16" OSB ranged from $12-18 per sheet for pallet quantities (48-60 sheets per pallet) in the Southeast U.S., based on quotes from three distributors. Verify current pricing—this swings monthly with lumber markets.
  • Ask about "mill run" or "brand second" OSB if you want to save money. But know what you're getting: irregular edges and thickness variations mean more labor culling bad boards. One project saved $2,200 on material this way, then paid $3,100 in extra labor. Learn from my mistake. We bought mill run once in 2024. Never again.

How to Determine Which Scenario You're In

Here's the framework I now give people when they ask:

  1. Square footage: Under 5,000 sq ft, go DIY (Scenario C). 10,000-40,000 sq ft with interior-only work, consider Scenario B. Anything with structural scope or 50,000+ sq ft, Scenario A.
  2. Permit requirements: "Tenant improvement with no structural work" is often expedited. But if your jurisdiction requires a full building permit and stamped drawings, you need a licensed architect. Period.
  3. Schedule buffer: If you have a hard move-in date, a global firm's review process might actually save you time—they've navigated city permitting processes many times. If your timeline is flexible, a dedicated small studio can give you more senior attention for the same fee range.
  4. Your in-house bandwidth: Be honest. Do you have someone who can track submittal logs, RFIs, and material approvals? If not, a firm like Gensler provides that infrastructure. If yes, you can save fees by wearing that hat yourself.

My experience is based on about a dozen commercial fit-out and renovation projects across three companies over five years. It's a decent sample, but I've only worked with domestic vendors and standard office construction. If you're working on a healthcare facility, data center, or anything with specialized code requirements, your constraints will be different—especially around cement board certifications, where you may need UL-listed assemblies.

The Bottom Line

Whether you engage Gensler or buy your own OSB sheets, the fundamental question is the same one I face in any purchasing decision: what am I paying for, and is the added capability worth what it costs?

A global design firm brings capability. Direct material procurement brings control. The right answer depends on which your project needs more.

Also: always ask for the mill certificate.

Emilia Novak
Emilia Novak

Emilia Novak is a flooring and architectural-surfaces analyst covering ceramic and porcelain tile, natural stone, resilient flooring, underlayments, countertops, adhesives, grout, and installation accessories. She uses ASTM C373 and ASTM C648 test evidence while comparing water absorption, breaking strength, slab flatness, substrate moisture, joint width, slip resistance, and installed tolerances. Her specification guides help architects, contractors, and buyers match surface systems to traffic, wet-area exposure, maintenance demands, and substrate conditions.